Old vs new tax regime: which one actually suits you?

There is no regime that suits everyone. The comparison turns on how much you actually claim as deductions. If your deductions are modest, the new regime's lower rates usually work out better; if you carry substantial housing interest or long-standing investment-linked deductions, the old regime often still wins. The only reliable method is to compute your liability both ways for the year in question.
Why the slab comparison misleads people
Most comparisons put the two rate tables side by side and stop there. That is the least useful way to look at it, because the regimes are not just different rates on the same base. They tax different bases.
The new regime offers lower rates but withdraws most of the deductions and exemptions people are used to claiming. The old regime keeps those deductions but taxes what remains at higher rates. So the question is never "which slabs are lower". It is whether the deductions you actually claim are worth more to you than the rate reduction you would give up.
The figure that decides it
For most people the decision comes down to a single number: the total of the deductions and exemptions you genuinely claim each year, not the ones you could theoretically claim.
This is where we see the most common error. People add up every deduction they have heard of and conclude the old regime is better, when in practice they claim only a fraction of them. Work from your last filed return rather than from intention.
Housing loan interest is often the item that tips the balance, because it can be substantial and runs for years. Long-standing investment-linked deductions and certain allowances can matter too, depending on how your salary is structured.
When the answer is usually clear
There are two ends where the comparison rarely surprises anyone.
If you claim little beyond the standard deduction, have no housing loan, and your salary is not structured around allowances, the new regime generally comes out ahead.
If you are servicing a significant housing loan and have a mature set of investment-linked deductions built up over years, the old regime often still comes out ahead.
Between those two ends, it is genuinely close, and it moves as the rates and thresholds are revised. That middle group should compute both every year rather than settling on a regime once and leaving it.
What to do about it
Run both computations on your actual figures for the year in question, not on last year's rules. The thresholds, rebates and the standard deduction have all been revised in recent years, and a conclusion that held two years ago may not hold now.
Frequently asked questions
Can I switch between the regimes each year?
Salaried individuals without business income have generally been permitted to choose each year. Where there is business or professional income the ability to switch back is more restricted. The rules here have changed more than once, so confirm the position for the year you are filing.
Is the new regime always better if I have no deductions?
Usually, but not automatically. Compute both. The result depends on your income level and on the exemptions and rebates in force for that year.
Does my employer's choice bind me?
No. What you declare to your employer governs how tax is deducted from your salary during the year. Your final position is settled in your return.