Statutory audit vs internal audit: what is the difference?

A statutory audit is required by law and produces an independent opinion, addressed to the shareholders, on whether the financial statements give a true and fair view. An internal audit is commissioned by the business itself and looks at whether its processes and controls are working. One is an external obligation with a defined output; the other is a management tool with whatever scope management sets.
They answer different questions
The confusion is understandable, because both involve an accountant examining the business. But they are asking different questions on behalf of different people.
A statutory audit asks whether the financial statements, taken as a whole, give a true and fair view. It is required by law, it follows prescribed standards, and it ends in a formal opinion addressed to the members of the company. The auditor is independent of the business and is not there to help management run it.
An internal audit asks whether the way the business operates is sound: are the controls doing what they are supposed to do, are the processes being followed, where is the exposure. It is commissioned by the business, its scope is set by management or the audit committee, and it reports back to them.
Who the work is for
This is the distinction that matters most in practice, and it explains most of the others.
The statutory auditor's work exists for people outside the business: shareholders, lenders, regulators, anyone relying on the accounts. That is why independence is not negotiable and why the output is a defined opinion rather than a list of suggestions.
The internal auditor's work exists for people inside the business. The output is findings and recommendations, and its value lies in being acted upon.
Scope and timing
A statutory audit has a scope largely determined by the standards and the financial statements themselves. It happens on a defined cycle tied to the financial year.
An internal audit has whatever scope is agreed. It might look at procurement one quarter and revenue recognition the next. It can run continuously through the year, and it is often most useful when it does.
When a business needs each
The statutory audit is generally not a choice. Where the obligation applies, it applies, and the thresholds that determine it are revised periodically.
Internal audit is a choice for most businesses, and the case for it usually arrives with growth. Once transaction volumes rise past the point where the owner can see everything personally, or once the business has locations, subsidiaries or a management layer between the owner and the ledger, the gap that internal audit fills becomes real.
Companies sometimes discover this the wrong way round, when a statutory audit surfaces a control weakness that had been quietly costing money for a while.
Frequently asked questions
Can the same firm do both?
Independence requirements restrict this. A firm giving an independent opinion on financial statements cannot generally also be reviewing the internal controls that produce them. The specific restrictions depend on the company and the applicable rules.
Does every company need a statutory audit?
Companies incorporated under the Companies Act are generally subject to statutory audit. For other entities it depends on the form of the entity and on thresholds that are revised from time to time.
Is internal audit ever mandatory?
For certain classes of company it is. For everyone else it is voluntary, and businesses commission it because they want the assurance rather than because they are required to.